8.3.4International comparison of Belgium and Flanders’ participation in the European Defence Fund 2021-2022

Since the data for 2023 is not yet complete, the following analysis continues for the period 2021-2022, the initial period of the EDF. This concerns about 92 projects, with 1596 participations (non-unique actors) for a total support of 1,675 billion euros. We would like to note that we are focusing here on the EDF support and the share of Belgium and Flanders within this amount (and not on the total project budget).

The 65 Belgian participations account for EDF support of 58,6 million euros. The 20 Flemish participations account for an amount of 24,4 million euros divided over 17 projects. It is important to note that we include the Von Karman Institute (VKI) in the following analysis as a Flemish actor (and not as a federal actor). The Flemish participations with budget are shown in the Table 3 below. Some clarifications regarding the table below:

  • For the call EDF2022-LS-RA-CHALLENGE-DIGIT-HTDP, two consortia/projects, namely AIDEDex and CONVOY, signed up with Flemish partners.
  • Two Flemish partners are participating in the RESILIENCE project.
  • Three Flemish partners are participating in the EDF2021-EPW project.
     

Table 3. Overview Flemish participation in the EDF (2021-2022)

EDF-CallsProjectTopicFlemish participationNumber of Flemish participants
2021-AIR-D-CAC-2EICACSAir combat1300001
2021-ENERENV-D-PES-2NEUMANNEnergy and environment38628251
2021-GROUND-D-3CA-2MARSEUSGround combat5110281
2021-MATCOMP-R-RF-2AGAMI_EURIGAMIMaterials and components10361861
2021-PROTMOB-D-SS-2ACHILEForce protection and mobility4975111
2021-SENS-R-IRD-2HEROICSensors37936261
2021-SPACE-D-EPW-2EDF-2021-EPWSpace50610633
2021-SPACE-D-SGNS-2NAVGUARDSpace5720001
2022-DA-C4ISR-SOFC2PROTEASInformation superiority3459601
2022-DA-NAVAL-MSASEUROGUARDNaval35981391
2022-DA-SPACE-ISRSPIDERSpace6401681
2022-FPA-MCBRN-MCMRESILIENCEMedical resonse and CBRN02
2022-LS-RA-CHALLENGE-DIGIT-HTDPAIDEDexDigital transformation16778561
2022-LS-RA-CHALLENGE-DIGIT-HTDPCONVOYDigital transformation3000001
2022-LS-RA-DIS-EADTHEMADisruptive technologies6484801
2022-LS-RA-DIS-NTSILENTDisruptive technologies7999741
2022-RA-MCBRN-HICPiMEDCAPMedical resonse and CBRN9999951
Total 2447480920
EDF-CallsProjectTopicFlemish participationNumber of Flemish participants
2021-AIR-D-CAC-2EICACSAir combat1300001
2021-ENERENV-D-PES-2NEUMANNEnergy and environment38628251
2021-GROUND-D-3CA-2MARSEUSGround combat5110281
2021-MATCOMP-R-RF-2AGAMI_EURIGAMIMaterials and components10361861
2021-PROTMOB-D-SS-2ACHILEForce protection and mobility4975111
2021-SENS-R-IRD-2HEROICSensors37936261
2021-SPACE-D-EPW-2EDF-2021-EPWSpace50610633
2021-SPACE-D-SGNS-2NAVGUARDSpace5720001
2022-DA-C4ISR-SOFC2PROTEASInformation superiority3459601
2022-DA-NAVAL-MSASEUROGUARDNaval35981391
2022-DA-SPACE-ISRSPIDERSpace6401681
2022-FPA-MCBRN-MCMRESILIENCEMedical resonse and CBRN02
2022-LS-RA-CHALLENGE-DIGIT-HTDPAIDEDexDigital transformation16778561
2022-LS-RA-CHALLENGE-DIGIT-HTDPCONVOYDigital transformation3000001
2022-LS-RA-DIS-EADTHEMADisruptive technologies6484801
2022-LS-RA-DIS-NTSILENTDisruptive technologies7999741
2022-RA-MCBRN-HICPiMEDCAPMedical resonse and CBRN9999951
Total 2447480920
EDF-CallsProjectTopicFlemish participationNumber of Flemish participants
2021-AIR-D-CAC-2EICACSAir combat1300001
2021-ENERENV-D-PES-2NEUMANNEnergy and environment38628251
2021-GROUND-D-3CA-2MARSEUSGround combat5110281
2021-MATCOMP-R-RF-2AGAMI_EURIGAMIMaterials and components10361861
2021-PROTMOB-D-SS-2ACHILEForce protection and mobility4975111
2021-SENS-R-IRD-2HEROICSensors37936261
2021-SPACE-D-EPW-2EDF-2021-EPWSpace50610633
2021-SPACE-D-SGNS-2NAVGUARDSpace5720001
2022-DA-C4ISR-SOFC2PROTEASInformation superiority3459601
2022-DA-NAVAL-MSASEUROGUARDNaval35981391
2022-DA-SPACE-ISRSPIDERSpace6401681
2022-FPA-MCBRN-MCMRESILIENCEMedical resonse and CBRN02
2022-LS-RA-CHALLENGE-DIGIT-HTDPAIDEDexDigital transformation16778561
2022-LS-RA-CHALLENGE-DIGIT-HTDPCONVOYDigital transformation3000001
2022-LS-RA-DIS-EADTHEMADisruptive technologies6484801
2022-LS-RA-DIS-NTSILENTDisruptive technologies7999741
2022-RA-MCBRN-HICPiMEDCAPMedical resonse and CBRN9999951
Total 2447480920

Source: FT-portal – extraction November 2024


The data allows us to look at the share that Belgium and Flanders take in the EDF budget. France, Germany, Italy, and Spain together account for about 65% of the EDF budget. Belgium ranks 8th with a share of 3,5%. Flanders accounts for about 1,5% of the budget and represents 1,3% of the total number of participations (see Figure 2).

Figure 2. Share of Belgium and Flanders in EDF projects based on the budget and number of participants (2021-2022)

Source: FT-portal – extraction November 2024

The data also allows us to examine the share that Belgian and Flemish actors take in the projects they participate in, with a focus on the EDF budget. This share is shown in the Table 4 below. In some projects, this includes a share of more than 20% of the EDF budget. One of the projects, namely RESILIENCE, involves participation (in 2022) without a budget[1].

[1] This concerns more an agreement to collaborate

Table 4. Overview of Belgian and Flemish project participation – share in the budget (2021-2022)

ProjectShare Belgium EDF budgetShare Flanders EDF budget
AIDEDex52,5%33,6%
AMLTD34,9%
EDF-2021-EPW21,5%20,2%
HEROIC21,1%21,1%
TeChBioT20,9%
SILENT20,1%20,1%
CONVOY19,8%6,0%
MARSEUS18,3%2,0%
P2P-FSO15,2%
ALTISS15,0%
HEGAPS10,0%
FAMOUS29,2%
NEUMANN7,9%7,9%
ACTING7,0%
NAVGUARD6,7%2,3%
LATACC6,4%
EUROGUARD6,4%5,5%
INDY6,3%
POWERPACK6,1%
POWERFLEX5,8%
IntSen25,2%
ACHILE4,8%1,2%
THEMA4,3%4,3%
EDINAF4,2%
AGAMI_EURIGAMI4,2%4,2%
PROTEAS4,2%1,7%
SWAT-SHOAL4,0%
iMEDCAP4,0%4,0%
COUNTERACT2,6%
FACT2,0%
EUCINF2,0%
dTHOR1,8%
SPIDER1,6%1,6%
FASETT1,5%
SCUALE1,3%
FaRADAI1,2%
ODINS EYE II1,1%
EICACS0,2%0,2%
RESILIENCE0,0%0,0%
Total share EDF budget5,9%5,3%
ProjectShare Belgium EDF budgetShare Flanders EDF budget
AIDEDex52,5%33,6%
AMLTD34,9%
EDF-2021-EPW21,5%20,2%
HEROIC21,1%21,1%
TeChBioT20,9%
SILENT20,1%20,1%
CONVOY19,8%6,0%
MARSEUS18,3%2,0%
P2P-FSO15,2%
ALTISS15,0%
HEGAPS10,0%
FAMOUS29,2%
NEUMANN7,9%7,9%
ACTING7,0%
NAVGUARD6,7%2,3%
LATACC6,4%
EUROGUARD6,4%5,5%
INDY6,3%
POWERPACK6,1%
POWERFLEX5,8%
IntSen25,2%
ACHILE4,8%1,2%
THEMA4,3%4,3%
EDINAF4,2%
AGAMI_EURIGAMI4,2%4,2%
PROTEAS4,2%1,7%
SWAT-SHOAL4,0%
iMEDCAP4,0%4,0%
COUNTERACT2,6%
FACT2,0%
EUCINF2,0%
dTHOR1,8%
SPIDER1,6%1,6%
FASETT1,5%
SCUALE1,3%
FaRADAI1,2%
ODINS EYE II1,1%
EICACS0,2%0,2%
RESILIENCE0,0%0,0%
Total share EDF budget5,9%5,3%
ProjectShare Belgium EDF budgetShare Flanders EDF budget
AIDEDex52,5%33,6%
AMLTD34,9%
EDF-2021-EPW21,5%20,2%
HEROIC21,1%21,1%
TeChBioT20,9%
SILENT20,1%20,1%
CONVOY19,8%6,0%
MARSEUS18,3%2,0%
P2P-FSO15,2%
ALTISS15,0%
HEGAPS10,0%
FAMOUS29,2%
NEUMANN7,9%7,9%
ACTING7,0%
NAVGUARD6,7%2,3%
LATACC6,4%
EUROGUARD6,4%5,5%
INDY6,3%
POWERPACK6,1%
POWERFLEX5,8%
IntSen25,2%
ACHILE4,8%1,2%
THEMA4,3%4,3%
EDINAF4,2%
AGAMI_EURIGAMI4,2%4,2%
PROTEAS4,2%1,7%
SWAT-SHOAL4,0%
iMEDCAP4,0%4,0%
COUNTERACT2,6%
FACT2,0%
EUCINF2,0%
dTHOR1,8%
SPIDER1,6%1,6%
FASETT1,5%
SCUALE1,3%
FaRADAI1,2%
ODINS EYE II1,1%
EICACS0,2%0,2%
RESILIENCE0,0%0,0%
Total share EDF budget5,9%5,3%

Source: FT-portal – extraction November 2024

Belgium is the coordinator of 3 projects, with Flanders taking responsibility for 2 of them. France is clearly the most dominant party, taking on a coordinator role in 34% of the projects. France is followed by Spain (17%), Germany (10%), and Greece (9%).

Table 5. Overview of coordinator role in EDF-projects per country

CountryCoordinator
France33,7%
Spain17,4%
Germany9,8%
Greece8,7%
Italy5,4%
Slovenia4,3%
Belgium3,3%
Flanders2,2%
Austria2,2%
Estonia2,2%
Norway2,2%
Portugal2,2%
Sweden2,2%
Bulgaria1,1%
Denmark1,1%
Finland1,1%
Latvia1,1%
Netherlands1,1%
Poland1,1%
CountryCoordinator
France33,7%
Spain17,4%
Germany9,8%
Greece8,7%
Italy5,4%
Slovenia4,3%
Belgium3,3%
Flanders2,2%
Austria2,2%
Estonia2,2%
Norway2,2%
Portugal2,2%
Sweden2,2%
Bulgaria1,1%
Denmark1,1%
Finland1,1%
Latvia1,1%
Netherlands1,1%
Poland1,1%
CountryCoordinator
France33,7%
Spain17,4%
Germany9,8%
Greece8,7%
Italy5,4%
Slovenia4,3%
Belgium3,3%
Flanders2,2%
Austria2,2%
Estonia2,2%
Norway2,2%
Portugal2,2%
Sweden2,2%
Bulgaria1,1%
Denmark1,1%
Finland1,1%
Latvia1,1%
Netherlands1,1%
Poland1,1%

Source: FT-portal – extraction November 2024